North Star Pizza & Ice Cream Shop
  • Photos
  • Menu
  • Location
  • Work Hours
  • Business info
  • Reviews

North Star Pizza & Ice Cream Shop Menu

Menu North Star Pizza & Ice Cream Shop-1
Menu North Star Pizza & Ice Cream Shop-1
Menu North Star Pizza & Ice Cream Shop-2
Menu North Star Pizza & Ice Cream Shop-2

PIZZA OF THE MONTH - BUFFALO CHICKEN

Large Buffalo Chicken Pizza
$20.24
Our in homemade crust with Buffalo sauce, cheddar cheese mix, bacon, onions, chicken and one side of ranch
Medium Buffalo Chicken Pizza
$17.24
Our in homemade crust with Buffalo sauce, cheddar cheese mix, bacon, onions, chicken and one side of ranch
Small Buffalo Chicken Pizza
$14.24
Our in homemade crust wtih Buffalo sauce, cheddar cheese mix, bacon, onions, chicken and one side of ranch
Personal Buffalo Chicken Pizza
$10.24
Our in homemade crust with Buffalo sauce, cheddar cheese mix, bacon, onions, chicken and one side of ranch
GF Detroit Style Buffalo Chicken Pizza
$13.75
" x " gluten free crust with Buffalo sauce, cheddar cheese mix, bacon, onions, chicken and one side of ranch
GF " Crust Buffalo Chicken Pizza
$18.50
" gluten free crust with Buffalo sauce, cheddar cheese mix, bacon, onions, chicken and one side of ranch

Game Day Special Large -Topping Pizzas

Large One Topping Pizzas
$29.00

" Personal

Personal BYO Pizza
$9.24
Personal " Build-Your-Own Pizza, your choice of toppings
Personal Deluxe Pizza
$12.24
Pepperoni, sausage, onions, green olives, banana peppers, mushrooms
Personal Buffalo Chicken Pizza
$12.24
Buffalo sauce, cheddar cheese mix, bacon, onions, chicken, and one side of ranch
Personal BBQ Chicken Pizza
$12.24
Home-made BBQ sauce, cheddar cheese mix, bacon, onions, chicken, and one side of ranch
Personal White Chicken Pizza
$12.24
White garlic sauce, mozzarella & parmesan cheeses, chicken
Personal Cheeseburger Pizza
$12.24
Our in homemade crust with Thousand Island sauce, mixed cheese, beef, bacon, onions, pickles, diced tomatoes. Topped with American Cheese, lettuce & a final drizzle of Thousand Island.
Personal Meat Pizza
$12.24
pepperoni, sausage, ham, beef, bacon
Personal Veggie Pizza
$11.24
mushrooms, banana peppers, onions, green olives, green peppers
Personal Hawaiian Pizza
$9.24
ham, pineapples, banana peppers

" Small

Small BYO Pizza
$11.24
Small " Build-Your-Own Pizza, your choice of toppings
Small Deluxe Pizza
$16.24
Pepperoni, sausage, onions, green olives, banana peppers, mushrooms
Small Buffalo Chicken Pizza
$16.24
Buffalo sauce, cheddar cheese mix, bacon, onions, chicken, and one side of ranch
Small BBQ Chicken Pizza
$16.24
Home-made BBQ sauce, cheddar cheese mix, bacon, onions, chicken, and one side of ranch
Small White Chicken Pizza
$16.24
White garlic sauce, mozzarella & parmesan cheeses, chicken
Small Cheeseburger Pizza
$16.24
Our in homemade crust with Thousand Island sauce, mixed cheese, beef, bacon, onions, pickles, diced tomatoes. Topped with American Cheese, lettuce & a final drizzle of Thousand Island.
Small Meat Pizza
$15.24
pepperoni, sausage, ham, beef, bacon
Small Veggie Pizza
$14.24
mushrooms, banana peppers, onions, green olives, green peppers
Small Hawaiian Pizza
$10.24
ham, pineapples, banana peppers
Small Half & Half Specialty
$5.75

" Medium

Medium BYO Pizza
$13.25
Medium " Build-Your-Own Pizza, your choice of toppings
Medium Deluxe Pizza
$19.24
Pepperoni, sausage, onions, green olives, banana peppers, mushrooms
Medium Buffalo Chicken Pizza
$19.24
Buffalo sauce, cheddar cheese mix, bacon, onions, chicken, and one side of ranch
Medium BBQ Chicken Pizza
$19.24
Home-made BBQ sauce, cheddar cheese mix, bacon, onions, chicken, and one side of ranch
Medium White Chicken Pizza
$19.34
White garlic sauce, mozzarella & parmesan cheeses, chicken
Medium Cheeseburger Pizza
$19.24
Thousand Island sauce, mixed cheese, beef, bacon, onions, pickles, diced tomatoes. Topped with American Cheese, lettuce & a final drizzle of Thousand Island.
Medium Meat Pizza
$18.24
pepperoni, sausage, ham, beef, bacon
Medium Veggie Pizza
$17.24
mushrooms, banana peppers, onions, green olives, green peppers
Medium Hawaiian Pizza
$13.24
ham, pineapples, banana peppers
Medium Half & Half Specialty
$6.75

" Large

Large BYO Pizza
$15.25
Large " Build-Your-Own Pizza, your choice of toppings
Large Deluxe Pizza
$22.24
Pepperoni, sausage, onions, green olives, banana peppers, mushrooms
Large Buffalo Chicken Pizza
$22.25
Buffalo sauce, cheddar cheese mix, bacon, onions, chicken, and one side of ranch
Large BBQ Chicken Pizza
$22.24
Home-made BBQ sauce, cheddar cheese mix, bacon, onions, chicken, and one side of ranch
Large White Chicken Pizza
$22.24
White garlic sauce, mozzarella & parmesan cheeses, chicken
Large Cheeseburger Pizza
$22.24
Thousand Island sauce, mixed cheese, beef, bacon, onions, pickles, diced tomatoes. Topped with American Cheese, lettuce & a final drizzle of Thousand Island.
Large Meat Pizza
$21.24
pepperoni, sausage, ham, beef, bacon
Large Veggie Pizza
$20.24
mushrooms, banana peppers, onions, green olives, green peppers
Large Hawaiian Pizza
$16.24
ham, pineapples, banana peppers
Large Half & Half Specialty
$7.75

Gluten Free Detroit Style Crust

GF Detroit Style BYO Pizza
$12.75
Build-Your-Own Pizza " x " with your choice of toppings
GF Detroit Style Deluxe Pizza
$15.75
" x " with pepperoni, sausage, onions, green olives, banana peppers, mushrooms
GF Detroit Style Buffalo Chicken Pizza
$15.75
" x " with buffalo sauce, cheddar cheese mix, bacon, onions, chicken, and one side of ranch
GF Detroit Style BBQ Chicken Pizza
$15.75
" x " with our home-made BBQ sauce, cheddar cheese mix, bacon, onions, chicken, and one side of ranch
GF Detroit Style White Chicken Pizza
$15.75
" x " with white garlic sauce, mozzarella & parmesan cheeses, chicken
GF Detroit Style Cheeseburger Pizza
$15.75
" x " with Thousand Island sauce, mixed cheese, beef, bacon, onions, pickles, diced tomatoes. Topped with American Cheese, lettuce & a final drizzle of Thousand Island.
GF Detroit Style Meat Pizza
$15.75
" x " with pepperoni, sausage, ham, beef, bacon
GF Detroit Style Veggie Pizza
$14.75
" x " with mushrooms, banana peppers, onions, green olives, green peppers
GF Detroit Style Hawaiian Pizza
$12.75
" x " with ham, pineapples, banana peppers

Gluten Free " Crust

GF " Crust BYO Pizza
$15.50
A " GF Build-Your-Own Pizza, your choice of toppings
GF " Crust Deluxe Pizza
$20.50
" GF with pepperoni, sausage, onions, green olives, banana peppers, mushrooms
GF " Crust Buffalo Chicken Pizza
$20.50
" GF with buffalo sauce, cheddar cheese mix, bacon, onions, chicken, and one side of ranch
GF " Crust BBQ Chicken Pizza
$20.50
" GF with home-made BBQ sauce, cheddar cheese mix, bacon, onions, chicken, and one side of ranch
GF " Crust White Chicken Pizza
$20.50
" GF with white garlic sauce, mozzarella & parmesan cheeses, chicken
GF " Crust Cheeseburger Pizza
$20.50
" GF with Thousand Island sauce, mixed cheese, beef, bacon, onions, pickles, diced tomatoes. Topped with American Cheese, lettuce & a final drizzle of Thousand Island.
GF " Crust Meat Pizza
$19.50
" GF with pepperoni, sausage, ham, beef, bacon
GF " Crust Veggie Pizza
$18.50
" GF with mushrooms, banana peppers, onions, green olives, green peppers
GF " Crust Hawaiian Pizza
$14.50
" GF with ham, pineapples, banana peppers

Extra Sides of Sauce

Marinara
$1.00
Garlic Sauce
$1.00
Ranch
$1.00
Hot Sauce
$1.00
BBQ
$1.00
Honey Mustard
$1.00
Ketchup
$1.00
Mustard
$1.00
Mayo
$1.00

Breadsticks

Regular Breadsticks
$7.24
baked plain breadsticks and choice of one marinara sauce or garlic butter
Garlic Breadsticks
$7.74
baked New York style garlic breadsticks and choice of one marinara sauce or garlic butter
Cinnamon Breadsticks
$7.49
breadsticks topped with cinnamon sugar, served with icing
Garlic Bread
$4.74
inch baked garlic bread and choice of one marinara sauce or garlic butter

Wings

Boneless Wings
$7.75
Bone-In Wings
$8.25

Strombolis

One Topping Stromboli
$8.24
Cheese, choice of one topping, and choice of one marinara sauce or garlic butter
Regular Stromboli
$9.23
Cheese, pepperoni, spicy sausage, onions, green peppers, and choice of one marinara sauce or garlic butter
Hawaiian Stromboli
$9.24
Cheese, ham, pineapple, banana peppers, and choice of one marinara sauce or garlic butter
Grilled Chicken Stromboli
$9.99
Cheese, grilled chicken, bacon, onion, and choice of one marinara sauce or garlic butter

Subs

Italian Sub
$8.99
Ham, salami, pepperoni, cheese, onions, banana peppers, lettuce, tomato, and Italian dressing
Pizza Sub
$8.74
Pepperoni, pizza sauce, cheese, mushrooms, onions, and banana peppers
Dearth Sub
$7.99
A classic request, cheese & pepperoni is all you need on an inch sub!
Meatball Sub
$8.74
Pizza sauce, meatballs, and cheese
Ham & Cheese Sub
$8.99
Ham, cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo or honey mustard
Veggie Sub
$8.74
Onions, banana peppers, green olives, mushrooms, cheese, lettuce, tomato and choice of dressing
BLT Sub
$8.74
Bacon, lettuce tomato, cheese & mayo
Turkey Club Sub
$8.99
Turkey, ham, bacon, cheese, onions, banana peppers, lettuce, tomato, and choice of mayo or honey mustard
Grilled Chicken Sub
$8.99
Grilled chicken, bacon, onions, cheese, lettuce, tomato, choice of mayo, honey mustard or ranch dressing
Philly Steak Sub
$8.99
Chipped beef steak, green peppers, onions, cheese and mayo
Buffalo Chicken Sub
$8.99
Grilled chicken with buffalo sauce, cheddar & mozzarella cheese, bacon, onion, lettuce, tomato and ranch
Chicken Parmesan Sub
$8.99
Pizza sauce, chicken tenders, topped with mozzarella and parmesan cheese.

Salads

Side Salad
$4.99
lettuce, cheese, tomato, choice of dressing
Regular Salad
$6.89
lettuce, cheese, tomato, choice of dressings (serves - people)
Chef Salad
$8.89
lettuce, cheese, tomato, onions, green olives, banana peppers, mushrooms, choice of meat - ham, pepperoni or bacon, and choice of dressings
Grilled Chicken Salad
$9.89
lettuce, cheese, tomato, grilled chicken, bacon, onions, choice of dressings
Buffalo Chicken Salad
$9.89
lettuce, cheese, tomato, grilled chicken tossed in buffalo sauce, bacon, onions, choice of dressings

Sandwiches & More

Grilled Hot Dog
$3.99
Grilled hot dog on a bun
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
$5.99
Grilled chicken on a bun, with lettuce, tomato and mayo
Grilled Hamburger
$8.49
oz hamburger patty on a bun, with lettuce, tomato, pickle and mayo.
Chicken Tenders With Fries
$7.99
chicken tenders served with French fries
Kids Chicken Tenders With Fries
$5.99
chicken tenders served with French fries
Deep Fried Pickle Spears
$5.49
Crisp dill pickles in a beer batter coating with bit of spice. Add a side of ranch to cool things down.
Cheese Curds
$5.99
ounces of garlic, white cheddar cheese curds. Add a side of marinara
French Fries
$3.99
Side of French fries
Beef-N-Noodles With Mashed Potatoes
$8.99
SUNDAY ONLY served with mashed potatoes & dinner roll
Mashed Potatoes
$2.75
Side serving of mashed potatoes
Chips
$0.99
Conn's Potato Chips
Quart Of Mashed Potatoes
$6.00
One quart of mashed potatoes.
Quart Of Beef-N-Noodles
$8.50
quart of our Beef-n-Noodles
Quart Of Mashed Potatoes With Gravy
$7.00
One quart of mashed potatoes with a side of gravy large enough to cover.
Dinner Roll
$0.75

Ziti

Ziti, Single Size
$9.50
Family Size Ziti
$24.99
Garlic Bread
$4.74
inch baked garlic bread and choice of one marinara sauce or garlic butter

Desserts

Sugar Cookie
$1.49
North Star's home-made sugar cookie!
Brownies
$1.99
NEW Mint Brownie
$1.99
Brownies with a layer of mint
No Bake Cookie
$1.89
Chocolate Chip Cookie
$1.99
NEW Cherry Cheesecake Parfait
$4.25
Graham cracker crumb base with layers of cream cheese and cherry pie filling in a cup
Coconut Cream Pie
$3.99
Home-made Coconut Cream Pie
Peanut Butter Pie
$3.99
Home-made Peanut Butter Pie
NEW Butterfinger Pie
$3.99
On oreo crust covered with a peanut butter cream cheese filling, sprinkled with crushed Butterfingers. Topped with chocolate and more Butterfinger!
NEW Mounds Cake
$4.99
A layer of chocolate cake, creamy coconut filling & topped with chocolate!
NEW St. Patty's Cake
$4.99
Mint Poke Cake
$4.99
A delicious cake made with chocolate pudding, hot fudge and topped with Andes mint candies!
Chocolate Poke Cake
$4.99
Strawberry Cake
$4.99
Vanilla cake with strawberry swirls, topped with whip cream & fresh, sliced strawberries.
Pudding Cup (Flavors Subject To Change, Check Availability In Store When Picking Up)
$3.99
Red Velvet Poke Cake
$4.99
Caramel Heath Cake
$4.99
German chocolate cake drizzle with caramel and topped with whip topping and Heath bar
Caramel Snickers Cake
$4.99
Carrot Cake
$4.99
The layers of perfectly spiced Carrot Cake with shredded carrots & raisins. Cream cheese crossing lecorated with white chocolate chips & curls.
Caramel Butterfinger Cake
$4.99
German chocolate cake, drizzled with caramel and topped with Butterfinger
Cannoli Cake
$4.99
layers of mascarpone whipped cream frosting over a ricotta filled yellow cake with chocolate chips
Cheesecake (Flavors Subject To Change, Check Availability In Store When Picking Up)
$4.99
Cherry Cake
$4.99
Cinnamon Roll Cake
$4.99
Home-made cinnamon roll cake with home-made cream cheese icing.
Chocolate Chip Pudding Cake
$4.99
Oreo Cake
$4.99
Reese Cup Cake
$4.99
Rolo Cake
$4.99
Apple Caramel Cake
$4.99
Pumpkin Cheesecake
$4.99
Lemon Italian Cake
$4.99
Whole Coconut Cream Pie
$18.99
Whole Peanut Butter Pie
$18.99
Pumpkin Cookie
$1.59
Caramel Pumpkin Cream Cheese Cake
$4.99
Pumpkin cake with a whipped cream cheese icing drizzled in carmel.
Apple Pie
$3.99
Homemade apple pie
Blackberry Pie
$3.99
Home-made blackerry pie with locally sourced berries.
Cherry Pie
$3.99
Butter Pecan Cake
$4.99
Butter pecan cake, topped with a butterscotch-coconut whipped topping, sprinkled with pecans.
Cookies & Cream Dessert Cup
$3.99
Cream cheese and Oreos
Blackberry Cobbler
$4.25
Home-made blackerry cobbler made with local berries.
NEW Snickers Pie
$3.99
Graham cracker crust with a peanut butter, cool whip, snickers, and cream cheese filling. Topped with chocolate, caramel, and snickers!

Ice Cream

NEW Pumpkin Roll Sundae
$5.49
Homemade Pumpkin Roll setting on a scoop of Velvet Vanilla Ice Cream, topped with whipped cream
Root Beer Float
$4.99
oz. Root Beer float made with Velvet Ice Cream and Mug Root Beer
Hand Dipped Ice Cream
$0.50
Velvet Ice Cream
Milkshake
$4.99
Made with Velvet hand dipped and Smith Bros. Creamery Milk
Quart Hand Dipped
$6.00
Velvet Ice Cream

Fountain Drinks - Pepsi Products

Small- oz
$2.49
Medium- oz
$2.99
Large- Oz
$3.29
Small Water
$0.50
Medium Water
$0.75
Large Water
$1.00
Coffee - Oz
$1.00

Bag of Ice

Large Bag
$5.99
lbs
Small Bag
$3.99
lbs

North Star Pizza & Ice Cream Shop offers an extensive and delicious menu that’s sure to satisfy any craving, whether you’re in the mood for savory or sweet. The standout this month is the Buffalo Chicken Pizza, available in various sizes including large, medium, small, and personal options, as well as a gluten-free Detroit style. This spicy, tangy pizza is packed with flavor, perfect for those who love a little heat with their meal.

For pizza lovers, the menu offers a wide variety of choices, including BYO (Build Your Own) pizzas and Deluxe versions with a range of toppings. Choose from classics like the BBQ Chicken Pizza or White Chicken Pizza, both available in personal, small, medium, and large sizes. Gluten-free crust options are available for both Detroit-style and traditional pizzas, so everyone can enjoy a slice, regardless of dietary restrictions.

If you're looking for something to pair with your pizza, the Breadsticks are a must-try, with regular, garlic, and cinnamon varieties on offer. For an extra kick, don't forget to grab a side of marinara, garlic sauce, or ranch to dip your crusts into. The Wings—available in both boneless and bone-in styles—are another fan favorite, perfect for sharing or enjoying solo.

For something heartier, try one of the Strombolis, filled with a variety of savory ingredients like Hawaiian or grilled chicken, or opt for a classic Italian Sub or Meatball Sub. If you're in the mood for a lighter option, the Salads, such as the Buffalo Chicken Salad or Grilled Chicken Salad, make for a refreshing choice.

Finally, finish off your meal with a sweet treat! Indulge in a Pumpkin Roll Sundae, or enjoy some hand-dipped ice cream, perfect for those with a sweet tooth. And for the perfect drink, you can grab any Pepsi product, ensuring a refreshing end to your meal. Whether you're here for a quick bite or a full meal, North Star Pizza & Ice Cream Shop delivers a menu packed with tasty options for every palate.

North Star Pizza & Ice Cream Shop

North Star Pizza & Ice Cream Shop in Blue Rock, OH offers a delightful combination of pizza and handcrafted ice cream. With a variety of toppings and flavors, this cozy spot is perfect for families and groups. Enjoy their famous Buffalo Chicken Pizza or create your own masterpiece with their Personal BYO Pizza option. Don't forget to try their game day special for a satisfying meal. Experience great food, friendly service, and a stunning view of the Muskingum River at North Star Pizza & Ice Cream Shop.

Follow Us
  • Yelp
Copyright 2025 All rights reserved.